The Christmas tree in Bethlehem, the birthplace of Jesus according to Christian belief, has been lit for the first time since the Gaza war began, sparking a mix of emotions and opinions. But here's where it gets controversial: should celebrations resume while the conflict continues?
For two years, the usually bustling city of Bethlehem in the occupied West Bank saw its streets empty of tourists and its economy suffer. The ongoing war in Gaza cast a shadow over the city, leading to the cancellation of all public Christmas celebrations. However, with the recent ceasefire, Bethlehem has decided to bring back the festivities, starting with the lighting of its iconic Christmas tree.
"It's been a dark period," says Mayor Maher Canawati, reflecting on the absence of Christmas cheer and the devastating impact on the tourism-dependent city. But he acknowledges the ethical dilemma, as the suffering in Gaza persists, affecting its small Christian community with ties to Bethlehem.
The decision to celebrate has divided opinions. While some believe it's a sign of hope and a return to normalcy, others question the timing. The mayor, however, stands by his decision, emphasizing that Christmas represents light and hope, and should not be overshadowed by conflict.
The tree, adorned with red and gold ornaments, attracts locals and a few foreign tourists, eager to capture the moment. The city is slowly coming back to life, with colorful lights and advertisements for Christmas events. Local residents, regardless of faith, are thrilled to see the tree and the return of tourists, hoping to spread the true spirit of Christmas.
"Bethlehem is where it all began," says jewellery designer Nadya Hazboun, "and we want to show the world the essence of Christmas." She hopes that a peaceful Christmas in Bethlehem will send a powerful message of hope globally.
Nearby towns are joining the celebrations, and hotels are filling up with Israeli Palestinians and international visitors. One Russian tourist, Angelica, expresses her belief that everyone should visit the Holy Land at least once. She hopes for a revival of tourism, lamenting the lack of visitors and the silver lining of shorter lines at attractions.
Despite the renewed festivities, the economic challenges persist. Souvenir shops and tour guides, once bustling, now stand quiet. The war's impact on tourism and the Palestinian Authority's financial struggles have led to soaring unemployment. The situation is dire for many Palestinian Christians, who, despite the return of public events, face a subdued holiday season.
At the heart of Manger Square, a few customers line up for falafel, a traditional and affordable snack. Alaa Salameh, owner of a family restaurant, shares his concerns. He foresees a muted celebration, as many Christians struggle financially and cannot afford even simple pleasures like falafel.
As visitors explore the Nativity Church, tensions in the region remain. Locals pray for peace and eagerly await the return of tourists to the city that holds the origins of Christmas. But the question lingers: is it too soon to celebrate? What do you think? Should Bethlehem's celebrations be put on hold until the conflict is fully resolved, or is it a necessary step towards healing and hope?
